Discipline of Philosophy Speakers Series

Discipline of Philosophy Speakers Series presents Living without Beliefs by Daniel Vázquez (Mary Immaculate College) 

Time:  Tuesday, 20th January @ 1:00-2:30 pm (Lunch will be provided) 

Location:  THB G010

Abstract: In this talk, I shall argue that it is not only possible but also preferable to live without beliefs. I will begin by defining my terms and what I do not mean by this claim. But there is, I hope, no catch. I do not mean “belief” or “living” (or any of the other words) in any particularly idiosyncratic way. I am, of course, not the first one to argue for this thesis, so I shall offer, as an example among many, a brief outline of how ancient Greek sceptics defended it. This will include a brief look at texts and arguments by Pyrrho (c.360–270 BCE), Arcesilaus (315/4–241/40 BCE), Carneades (214–129/8 BCE), and Sextus Empiricus (fl. mid-late 2nd century CE). As I will explain, the interpretation of many of these philosophers is hotly debated and, in some cases, complicated by a lack of decisive evidence or by incompatible reports. For my purposes, however, I will highlight one possible interpretation of Carneades’ contributions, not because it is correct (though it might be), but for its philosophical potential and as a springboard for my own argument. I will conclude by outlining how, in my view, living without beliefs would positively affect our lives, relationships and politics, and would allow for morality, knowledge, and even faith.